"Keshwanand Bharti Case: A Landmark Decision in the Interpretation of the Indian Constitution"
 |
| Keshwananda Bharti Case |
Introduction:
The Keshwanand Bharti case, heard by the Supreme Court of India in 1973, is a crucial case in the interpretation of the Indian Constitution. The case dealt with the powers of the state government to amend the Constitution and established the principle of the "basic structure" of the Constitution. This case is important for UPSC exam preparation as it explains the limits of the powers of the state government to amend the Constitution and the principle of basic structure is still relevant today.
Background:
The case arose when the state government of Kerala passed
the Kerala Land Reforms (Amendment) Act, 1969. The act aimed to abolish the
"intermediate tenancy" system, under which landlords could lease
their land to intermediaries, who would then sub-lease the land to tenant farmers.
The act also sought to limit the amount of land that a person could own.
Keshwanand Bharti, a landlord, challenged the act on the grounds that it
violated his fundamental rights under the Constitution. He argued that the act
was a violation of his right to property and his right to equality before the
law.
The doctrine of the basic structure of the Indian Constitution
The doctrine of the basic structure of the Indian Constitution refers to the principle that certain fundamental features of the Indian Constitution are so essential that they cannot be amended or altered by the Parliament, even if it has the power to do so. These fundamental features, also known as the "basic structure" of the Constitution, are considered to be the foundation of the Constitution and are essential to its character and identity.
The concept of the
basic structure of the Constitution was first propounded by the Supreme Court
of India in the landmark case of Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala in
1973. In this case, the court held that certain basic features of the
Constitution are so fundamental that they cannot be amended or altered, even by
a constitutional amendment.
The basic structure of the Indian Constitution
includes:
- The republican and democratic forms of government
- The secular nature of the State
- The separation of powers among the three branches of government
- The federal structure of the Constitution
- The independence of the judiciary
- The protection of fundamental rights
It's important to note
that the basic structure of the Constitution is not defined in the Constitution
itself, but is rather a principle established by the courts to protect the
fundamental principles of the Constitution. The basic structure of the
Constitution is considered to be a flexible principle, and the list of basic
features may change over time.
Decision and Significance:
The Supreme Court upheld the act, but in a majority
judgment, the court held that the act was constitutional only to the extent
that it did not damage the "basic structure" of the Constitution. The
court established that the "basic structure" of the Constitution
includes fundamental rights and the federal structure of the government.
This principle of the "basic structure" has been invoked in several other cases, such as the Golaknath case and the Kesavananda Bharati case, and has been used to strike down several attempts to amend the Constitution.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, the Keshwanand Bharti case is an important landmark in the interpretation of the Indian Constitution and is essential for UPSC exam preparation. A thorough understanding of this case will help UPSC exam aspirants understand the limits of the powers of the state government to amend the Constitution and stay ahead in their exam preparation. The principle of "basic structure" established in this case is still relevant today and has been used in several other cases.